Facing a 3-1 series deficit against the Boston Celtics, the Orlando Magic found themselves in a critical game situation where star player Paolo Banchero quickly accumulated fouls early in the third quarter. Despite the risk, coach Jamahl Mosley decided to leave Banchero in the game due to the high stakes, knowing they couldn't afford to bench him and risk losing control of the game. Unfortunately, Banchero's inability to avoid further fouls led to his fifth foul shortly after, which the Magic unsuccessfully challenged. The decision to keep him in was a gamble that ultimately backfired, as the team lost momentum and fell behind significantly after Banchero's exit. The situation highlighted the need for Banchero to better manage his fouling and for the Magic to provide more defensive guidance in high-pressure scenarios.

Paolo Banchero quickly picked up three fouls early in the third quarter of a crucial game against the Celtics, with the Magic already facing elimination in the series.

Coach Jamahl Mosley chose to keep Banchero in the game despite the risk of further fouls, as benching him could have jeopardized the chances of winning the game.

Banchero received his fourth foul merely 15 seconds after the third, and then a fifth foul followed shortly, which the Magic unsuccessfully challenged.

With Banchero out of the game, the Magic lost their grip on the score, leading to a drastic shift from being tied at 53-53 to trailing by 21 points.

The situation underscored the need for Banchero to refine his defensive play to avoid fouling and for the Magic to develop strategies to better manage such scenarios.

The decision to keep Banchero in the game was a calculated risk in response to the urgency of the series, aiming to leverage his offensive capabilities to close the game.

Despite Banchero's talent and potential, his fouling issues became a significant impediment, demonstrating the importance of balancing aggressive play with discipline.

Sometimes, the logical decisions can still backfire.

The Orlando Magic entered Tuesday night facing a 3-1 series deficit to the Boston Celtics.

Knotted in a close game early in the third quarter, Magic superstar Paolo Banchero picked up his third foul 40 seconds into the second half.

Then 15 seconds later, he got his fourth foul. The Magic kept him in.

With 9:46 left in the third quarter, Banchero got his fifth foul. Orlando challenged it but was unsuccessful, losing their challenge the rest of the way.

At the time of Banchero's fifth foul, the game was tied, 53-53.

MORE: Giannis Antetokounmpo trade officially on the table for Bucks

It may have been unconventional from a basketball wisdom standpoint to leave Banchero in with four fouls.

Magic coach Jamahl Mosley did the logical thing, though. There'd be no tomorrow if they didn't win this game.

He couldn't afford to sit Banchero for 8-10 minutes and have the game get away.

Banchero had to stay in. The main issue was that he didn't do enough to avoid fouling during the process.

He's been a star in this series, proving he's worthy of the mantle of one of the league's up-and-coming studs.

But it was poor by Banchero to foul three times so quickly. The Magic needed him, and he played himself right off the floor in dumb fashion.

Orlando didn't do the wrong thing leaving Banchero in, but likely will need to provide a bit more guidance on these situations in the future to help him out defensively.

If Banchero simply doesn't foul, then he could've cooked offensively and made it a lot closer.

Ironically, maybe Orlando should've left him in with five fouls. The game quickly got away from the Magic.

Magic kind of needed Paolo, it seems. They led by 1 before he picked up his 5th, and 10 minutes later they trail by 21.

— Adam Himmelsbach (@AdamHimmelsbach) April 30, 2025

MORE: Tyrese Haliburton wins playoff series after unfathomable Gary Trent Jr. error