News Page

Main Content

No Fading in the Finals: Ranking the MVPs Who Backed It Up

Hunter Tierney 's profile
Original Story by Your Life Buzz
June 14, 2025
No Fading in the Finals: Ranking the MVPs Who Backed It Up

Winning MVP in the NBA is a huge deal — don’t get it twisted. You’ve just outplayed and outlasted the best in the world for six straight months, and the league basically stamped your season as the season. But here’s the thing: regular-season awards don’t mean a thing if you can’t finish the job in June.

Every year, the playoffs give us a chance to see whether that MVP shine holds up when the lights are brightest. And when those MVPs actually make it to the Finals? That’s when the microscope really zooms in. Some fade, some flounder, and then — every now and then — one of them absolutely owns the moment.

We’re diving into the rare air of guys who not only won the league’s highest individual honor, but then followed it up with a Finals performance that actually lived up to it. That’s a tight window — plenty of MVPs have come up short in June.

These are the all-time best Finals performances from players who took home the regular-season MVP, and (shocker) it’s chock-full of legends.

Honorable Mention – LeBron James, 2012: The Exhale

Jun 14, 2012; Oklahoma City, OK, USA; Miami Heat small forward LeBron James (6) drives against Oklahoma City Thunder small forward Kevin Durant (35) during the third quarter of game two in the 2012 NBA Finals at the Chesapeake Energy Arena.
Credit: Credit: Jerome Miron-Imagn Images

The Road Back from Heartbreak

LeBron’s 2011 Finals collapse wasn’t just a sports story — it was the story. The reaction was brutal. Everywhere you looked — TV, radio, online — it felt like the entire sports world was picking apart LeBron’s every move. Suddenly, the guy who’d just averaged near triple-double numbers in the playoffs was being labeled as someone who couldn’t close. Fair or not, that narrative stuck around. And let’s be honest — he gave the critics plenty to chew on that year.

But that’s what made the 2012 season feel different right from the jump. The league came back from the lockout and LeBron came back with tunnel vision. He was playing like he wanted revenge. In 62 games, he averaged 27 points, 8 boards, and 6 assists while shooting over 53% from the field, all while playing some of the best all-around basketball the league had seen in years.

By the time the Finals rolled around, it wasn’t just about winning a ring. It was about finally putting to rest the ghost of 2011 and proving that the best player in the world could also be the one who finished the job.

The Finals Snapshot

The Thunder were young, sure—but they also came in with serious momentum and no fear. Durant had just won the scoring title. Westbrook was pure chaos in motion. And James Harden, coming off a Sixth Man of the Year season, was the kind of wild card that could swing a game by himself. This was OKC’s first Finals appearance since the team moved from Seattle, and they came out hot, stealing Game 1 behind a furious second-half run.

But from that point on, the Heat just took over. LeBron was the engine behind it all, playing like a guy who was absolutely done answering questions about his past. He averaged 28.6 points, 10.2 rebounds, and 7.4 assists across the series, and what really stood out was how complete his game looked. He didn’t force shots. He didn’t disappear in the fourth. He just picked his spots, dominated defensively, and made the right play nearly every time down. And when he got to the free throw line, he didn’t waste trips — 90.5% from the stripe, a huge jump from the year before.

Game 5 was the punctuation mark. A triple-double — 26 points, 13 assists, 11 rebounds — with the Heat never letting OKC seriously threaten. It wasn’t flashy like some of the highlight-reel games we’ve seen over the years, but it was calm, confident, and surgical.

Why It Misses the Top 5

As good as LeBron was — and make no mistake, he was excellent — the reason this didn’t crack the top five comes down to a couple key things. For starters, let’s talk about that three-point shooting. LeBron shot just 19% from deep across the Finals. For a guy that controlled every other aspect of the game so well, that’s a pretty big blemish, especially in today’s era where spacing and perimeter shot-making are everything.

Then there’s the broader context. This was the first championship of what became the true ‘superteam’ era. Miami had three Hall of Famers in their prime, while OKC had three of their own, two of them were nowhere near their prime. The series only lasted five games, and outside of Game 2 and a little late-game drama in Game 4, it never felt like it was truly up for grabs.

LeBron finally got his ring, and in doing so, silenced a mountain of doubt. That alone makes this performance historic. But if we’re talking about the absolute best Finals showings by an MVP? There are a few others that edged this one out.

No. 5 – Magic Johnson, 1987: Junior Sky‑Hook, Senior Bragging Rights

Jun 1987; Los Angeles, CA, USA; FILE PHOTO; Los Angeles Lakers guard Magic Johnson (32) shoots the ball over Boston Celtics forward Darren Daye (20) during the 1987 NBA Finals at The Forum.
Credit: Credit: MPS-Imagn Images

Showtime’s Revenge Tour

The Lakers came into the 1986–87 season with a chip on their shoulder. After falling short in the '86 playoffs and watching Boston steamroll their way to another title, there was this underlying feeling in L.A. that they had something to prove.

Magic Johnson was at the center of that mission. He was already one of the league’s biggest stars, but this season was different. There was a sharper edge to his game. He pushed the tempo, set up his teammates like a maestro, and made sure the Lakers didn’t let up. On paper, he averaged 23.9 points and 12.2 assists, but that doesn’t even touch how much he controlled the floor. Every possession ran through him, and he made the whole thing hum.

When he was named MVP, it wasn’t just because of the stats — it was because he made winning look easy. And while he took a little jab at Bird, joking about Larry having an off year, everyone knew Magic had earned it. The Celtics were still lurking on the other side of the bracket, and everyone knew the rivalry wasn’t done. For Magic and the Lakers, this season was about reclaiming the crown. And they were locked in from day one.

Celtics, Garden, Everything on the Line

Boston was running on fumes. Kevin McHale was playing through a broken foot, basically gutting it out on one leg. Bill Walton, who had been a spark off the bench during their ’86 run, suited up in sweats more than in uniform. The Celtics’ starting five was still loaded, but the depth was paper thin and the wear and tear of a grueling playoff run was starting to show.

Still, beating a Larry Bird team — especially in the Finals — was never going to be easy. The Lakers came out hot, running Boston off the floor in Games 1 and 2 with that signature Showtime flair. But Game 3 saw the Celtics punch back hard, as Bird and McHale willed the team to a gritty win at the Garden.

That set the stage for Game 4 — one of the most iconic matchups in NBA Finals history. It wasn’t just pivotal for the series; it felt like a legacy game. Both teams knew what was at stake. The Garden was buzzing, the rivalry was at a boil, and what happened next would go down as one of the defining moments of Magic Johnson’s career.

One Shot to Silence Beantown

With just seven seconds left and the Lakers down one, everyone in the Garden knew the ball was going to Magic. The Celtics had seen him do this too many times. But even they probably didn’t expect that shot. Magic caught the inbound, drove hard down the lane—right into the teeth of Boston’s defense—and then pulled out a move that would get replayed for decades: the “junior sky-hook.”

It floated right over the outstretched arms of Kevin McHale and Robert Parish, two of the best shot-blockers of the era, and dropped through the net like it was scripted. The whole crowd went silent. Boston still had a look — Bird had a clean shot from the wing with time winding down — but it rimmed out. Game over.

Magic finished with 29 points, 8 assists, and 5 rebounds, but this game was never about the box score. It was about guts. It was about a player putting the ball in his hands with everything on the line and delivering the kind of shot you dream about as a kid.

Magic's Masterclass: Numbers, Narratives, and a Rivalry Rewritten

Over the course of the series, Magic Johnson averaged 26.2 points, 13 assists, 8 rebounds, and over two steals per game — numbers that really speak to how completely he controlled the game. He led the Lakers in assists every single night, and in scoring in three of the six games. It wasn’t just about stats, though. Magic dictated the pace, manipulated matchups, and always seemed to know exactly where the ball needed to go. His fingerprints were on everything the Lakers did.

When the dust settled, he earned his third Finals MVP, and the Lakers wrapped up their second title in three years. But this one carried more weight. It was against Boston.

Afterward, Larry Bird didn’t sugarcoat anything. He called Magic “the best I’ve ever seen.” And coming from Bird — one of the most competitive guys the league’s ever known — that meant a lot.

No. 4 – Tim Duncan, 2003: The Near Quadruple‑Double That Broke the Nets

FILE - In this June 15, 2003 file photo, San Antonio Spurs players Tim Duncan (21) holds his MVP trophy while teammate David Robinson (50) holds the championship trophy after the Spurs beat the New Jersey Nets 88-77 to win the NBA Championship in Game 6 of the NBA Finals in San Antonio.
Credit: Credit: AP Photo/Eric Gay via Imagn Images

Passing the Torch in San Antonio

Figuring out where to slot this one wasn’t easy. You could argue this one deserved to be even higher, and I wouldn’t push back too hard. The numbers, the control, the all-around dominance — it’s all there. Duncan’s 2003 Finals performance checks just about every box, and depending on what you value most, it could’ve easily climbed a spot.

But when it came down to the final ranking, this is where it landed. And even here, it stands as one of the most quietly devastating displays of control the Finals has ever seen.

David Robinson had already announced it was his final season, and the Spurs clearly wanted to send him out with one more ring. But this wasn’t a sentimental victory lap. It was very clearly Tim Duncan’s team now.

Duncan came into the Finals fresh off back-to-back MVPs, and in typical Tim Duncan fashion, you’d never know it unless you looked at the stat sheet. No media circus, no highlight-hunting — just cold, consistent dominance. He averaged 23 points, 13 rebounds, and 3 assists during the regular season, and he made it look easy.

What made it all so Spurs-y was how little noise surrounded it. The whole season felt like a slow, quiet buildup. The Spurs won 60 games that year and never really blinked. And behind it all was Duncan, calmly setting the tone for what would become a dynasty.

The Spurs Dynasty’s First True Statement

New Jersey came in playing fast and loose, led by Jason Kidd pushing tempo every chance he got. They wanted to run, get out in transition, and put pressure on the Spurs’ bigs to move. But Duncan wasn’t having any of it. He slowed the game to a crawl, anchoring San Antonio’s half-court sets and making sure every possession went through him, either by touch or gravity. The Nets were forced to play a style they weren’t built for, and it showed.

Duncan’s numbers across the series were straight out of a video game — 24.2 points, 17.0 rebounds, 5.3 assists, and 5.3 blocks per game — and somehow, it still doesn’t feel like it captures how dominant he was. His timing on the glass, his rim protection, his passing out of double teams — it all felt effortless.

Then came Game 6. Duncan finished with 21 points, 20 rebounds, 10 assists, and 8 blocks. The Spurs closed that game with a 19–0 run in the fourth, with Robinson pulling down 17 boards in his final act and Duncan orchestrating the whole thing like a conductor. In that moment, Duncan reset the standard for what quiet greatness could look like on the biggest stage.

Lasting Impact

That Game 6 launched a decade of dominance in San Antonio. You could see the DNA of their future in that moment: unselfish play, methodical execution, and defense that smothered you without all the flash. It was the perfect mix of grit and discipline, anchored by a guy who never needed to raise his voice to completely take over a game.

Duncan became just the fifth player ever to lead a title team in points, rebounds, and assists across an entire postseason. That’s not normal. And he did it all without ever looking for the spotlight.

In a league that loves drama and highlight reels, Duncan reminded everyone that dominance doesn’t have to be loud. Sometimes, it just shows up, handles business, and lets the banners do the talking.

No. 3 – Larry Bird, 1986: Peak Celtic Green

Larry Bird Hits Shot in 1986 Nba Finals
Credit: Credit: Boston Herald via Imagn Images

Home‑Court Heaven

Boston’s 67-win machine steamrolled through the league with a kind of polish and confidence that felt inevitable. They went 40–1 at the Garden, which seemed like a warning to every team walking in: it was going to take your best game, and then some, to get out of here with a win.

Larry Bird was in the middle of everything. He won his third straight MVP, and it wasn’t even a debate. He averaged 26 points, 10 rebounds, and 7 assists, which in that era was incredible. He just saw the game differently.

Bill Walton coming off the bench changed everything. He gave the Celtics life in second units, found cutters, and played like a guy grateful for a second shot at relevance. And the starting frontcourt of Kevin McHale and Robert Parish was a nightmare to deal with — McHale with his footwork and length, Parish with his toughness and timing. Together, they made life miserable for anyone trying to score inside.

It was a team built perfectly around its star, and Bird made sure everything clicked.

Finals vs. the ‘Twin Towers’ Rockets

The Rockets had serious talent with Hakeem Olajuwon and Ralph Sampson — two physical freaks who gave opponents fits in the paint. But they were still figuring it out, and Bird could sense it.

Houston did manage to grab Games 3 and 5, feeding off the home crowd energy and their size inside. But Boston never really looked panicked. They had too much experience, too much chemistry, and too much Bird.

Across the six-game series, he averaged 24.0 points, 9.7 rebounds, 9.5 assists, and 2.7 steals, doing just about everything for a Celtics team that relied on him to set the tone every night. Whether it was setting up cutters, boxing out bigs, or hitting timely threes, Bird found a way to make the game his. And by the end of the series, it was clear: he was the best player on the floor every night. 

Every time the Rockets punched, the Celtics calmly regrouped and came right back. They knew they were the better team, and they played like it, even when the series tightened up. Nothing about the moment seemed too big.

Two Triple‑Doubles & a Clincher for the Ages

Bird didn’t just put together one all-time Finals performance — he did it twice. He dropped two triple-doubles in the series, and each one felt like a masterclass in how to completely control a basketball game.

The first came in Game 3, on the road in Houston. Boston lost that one, but Bird was ridiculous. He racked up 25 points, 15 rebounds, and 11 assists while doing everything he could to keep the Celtics within striking distance.

Then came Game 6, the one that sealed the deal. Bird saved his best for last. He put up 29 points, 11 rebounds, and 12 assists, plus three steals in a closeout performance that was just ruthless. By halftime, he was already close to the triple-double mark, and in the second half, he pulled every string. Hit a jumper here, made the extra pass there, boxed out for an offensive board — you name it.

Jim Petersen, who had to go up against Bird, later said he could “demoralize a whole team.” And it wasn’t because he was loud or flashy. It was because he just wore you down, play after play, until there was no fight left.

Bigger Picture

’86 is the gold standard for Celtics fans, and Bird was the reason why. His ice-in-his-veins jumper and uncanny court vision turned an already dominant regular season into a Finals that still gets talked about like legend. But what made it truly wild was just how close he came to averaging a triple-double in the Finals — something that hadn’t ever been done at the time.

No. 2 – Michael Jordan, 1991: The Layup, the Legend, the Launch

Jun 12, 1991; Los Angeles, CA, USA: FILE PHOTO; Chicago Bulls guard Michael Jordan hugs the championship trophy as he celebrates winning the 1991 NBA Finals against the Los Angeles Lakers at The Forum. The Bulls defeated the Lakers 108-101 in game5 and won the series 4-1.
Credit: Credit: MPS-Imagn Images

Finally Past the Bad Boys

For years, the Bulls just couldn’t get past Detroit. The whole system was basically built around making Michael’s life miserable. They hit him, trapped him, pushed every limit, and for three straight postseasons, it worked. Each loss stung more than the last.

But by 1991, things changed. Jordan had matured, and so had the team around him. The Bulls didn’t just finally beat the Pistons — they swept them. And they didn’t pretend it was just business, either. Detroit walked off the court without shaking hands, a bitter end to a rivalry that had defined the East. But for Jordan, it was liberation. That weight he’d been carrying for years was finally gone.

So when he showed up in the Finals, regular-season MVP in hand, he looked ready; he looked free.

Showtime Shifts to the Windy City

Game 1 felt like a gut check. The Lakers came out swinging — Magic was putting on a clinic, Sam Perkins hit some huge threes, and just like that, the Bulls found themselves in an early hole. It could’ve been a momentum killer. But Jordan didn’t blink. He didn’t rush or force anything — he just took what the defense gave him and chipped away until Chicago was in control.

Over the next four games, MJ was locked in, averaging 31 points, 7 boards, and 11 dimes. He shot 55% from the field, even with the Lakers throwing everything they had at him — traps, doubles, help-side pressure. None of it fazed him. It was vintage Jordan, not in the sense of highlight dunks or angry stares, but in how surgical and unshakable he looked.

Signature Moment: The Mid‑Air Switch

Game 2, second half. Jordan takes off toward the rim, sees Sam Perkins sliding over, and just mid-air says, "Nope." He switches the ball to his left hand in flight — the kind of spontaneous move you can’t teach — and flips it in off the glass. Marv Albert lost it on the call. Every kid with a driveway and a dream tried (and failed) to pull that move off for the next decade.

That play didn’t win them the series, but it was the moment that let everyone watching know: this guy had fully arrived. It was the beginning of a whole new chapter for the NBA.

The Launchpad for a Bulls Dynasty

Jordan had been crowned MVP before, and we’d seen flashes of greatness plenty of times. But this was the first time it all translated into a title. The pieces around him had matured. Pippen was a full-on star. Horace Grant had carved out his role. And Phil Jackson had brought a calm to the chaos — a guiding hand that let Jordan be Jordan without needing him to carry the weight 48 minutes a night.

Once they got past the Lakers, it was like a floodgate opened. The '91 title gave the Bulls the swagger and proof of concept they needed. It wasn't whether they could win anymore — it was about how many times they would.

What followed was six titles in eight years and a cultural phenomenon that touched every corner of the sports world and beyond. But it all started here. 

No. 1 – Shaquille O’Neal, 2000: Planet Shaq in Full Orbit

Jun 2000; Indiana, IN, USA; FILE PHOTO; Los Angeles Lakers center Shaquille O'Neal (34) talks to guard Kobe Bryant (8) during a time-out against the Indiana Pacers during the 2000 NBA Finals at Canseco Fieldhouse.
Credit: Credit: Imagn Images

Peak of the Powerhouse

Phil Jackson arrived in L.A. with championship rings and a no-nonsense reputation, and he didn’t waste time setting the tone. He challenged Shaq to take things seriously — to dominate with intention, not just raw talent. And Shaq responded. The Lakers ripped off 67 wins that season, turning into a flat-out machine with O’Neal as the engine. He averaged 28 points, 13 boards, and 3 assists through the regular season.

He led the league in PER, Win Shares, and seemingly every advanced stat that existed. When he was locked in, there was nothing teams could do. Kobe was rising fast and turning into a star of his own, but in 2000, there was no debate — this was Planet Diesel.

The Finals: Pacers vs. a Freight Train

Larry Bird’s Pacers had shooting, IQ, and Reggie Miller doing his usual mix of talking and torching. But when it came to handling Shaquille O’Neal in the paint, they were flat-out outmatched. He was a one-man wrecking crew, and Indiana didn’t have a single body on the roster that could slow him down.

Across six games, Shaq averaged a mind-bending 38.0 points, 16.7 rebounds, and 2.7 blocks while shooting over 61% from the floor. Every game felt like a mismatch — not because Indiana wasn’t tough or smart, but because Shaq was just operating on a completely different level. He bullied his way through double-teams, shrugged off fouls, and made the paint his personal runway.

With Kobe Bryant limited for much of the series due to a nasty ankle sprain suffered in Game 2, Shaq had to shoulder even more of the offensive load. He didn’t flinch.

Starting Off With A Bang

Game 1 set the tone immediately. Shaq exploded for 43 points and 19 rebounds, absolutely overwhelming the Pacers’ frontcourt from the jump. There wasn’t a single answer for him — Indiana tried to body him up, send help, even force him into early foul trouble. None of it worked. The Lakers won comfortably, and Shaq made it crystal clear that this series was going to be played on his terms.

Then came Game 2, which turned into a parade to the line — Indiana went full Hack-a-Shaq, sending him to the stripe a jaw-dropping 39 times. He missed 21 of them, but it didn’t matter. He still bulldozed his way to 40 points and 24 rebounds, doing pretty much whatever he wanted in the paint. Afterward, he cracked, “Ugliest 40 I ever got.”

And as wild as that start was, he wasn’t done.

Game 6: The Finisher

With the title on the line, Shaq closed it out like only he could. He went for 41 points, 12 rebounds, and 4 blocks, taking over in a game where Kobe — still nursing that sprained ankle — could barely move. Shaq was the one steadying force all series, the focal point of everything the Lakers did. Finals MVP was unanimous, and he led the series in scoring every single night.

Complete Season Sweep

Only Willis Reed and Michael Jordan had previously managed to take home All‑Star MVP, regular-season MVP, Finals MVP, and the scoring title all in one year. Shaq joined that exclusive club in 2000. His dominance wasn’t subtle or surgical — it was loud, physical, and undeniable.

The league literally changed how games were officiated because of him, toning down the forearm shoves and brute-force post-ups that had become his calling card.

All stats courtesy of Pro Basketball Reference.

Latest Sports

Related Stories