NFL analyst says Giants will regret passing on Shedeur Sanders
The New York Giants made a pivotal decision during the NFL Draft by trading back into the first round to select quarterback Jaxson Dart from Ole Miss, bypassing Shedeur Sanders whom many thought they would choose. Kristopher Knox from Bleacher Report suggests the Giants may regret this choice, as Sanders might have been more pro-ready and capable of challenging the team's current starting quarterback, Wilson. Dart, while a strong fit schematically for head coach Brian Daboll's offense, presents risks due to his limited experience with progressions and heavy reliance on play-action offense. Knox warns that if the Giants' management fails to secure early wins with Dart under center, they might face job insecurity beyond 2025. Despite the potential missed opportunity with Sanders, who fell to the fifth round, the Giants' decision remains a topic of intense scrutiny and debate within the NFL community.
The New York Giants opted for Ole Miss quarterback Jaxson Dart over Shedeur Sanders during the NFL Draft, a decision that has sparked significant debate and scrutiny.
Kristopher Knox from Bleacher Report argues that Dart, although schematically a good fit for coach Brian Daboll's offense, may not be as ready as Sanders to compete for the starting position.
Dart comes from a play-action heavy offense and has limited ability to go through progressions, raising concerns about his readiness to lead the Giants effectively.
Sanders, who fell to the fifth round, was seen by some as a potentially safer choice who might have challenged the current starter, Wilson, during training camp.
The decision to draft Dart over Sanders is seen as risky, with Knox suggesting that early wins in 2025 are crucial for Daboll and general manager Joe Schoen to maintain their positions.
There is speculation that a new front office might build around Dart by 2026, potentially leading to regrets if Sanders proves to be the more capable quarterback.
The Giants' draft decision has placed them under the spotlight, with many eyes watching to see the long-term outcomes of their choice between Dart and Sanders.
The New York Giants made their decision on the direction of the franchise during the NFL Draft.
One of the critical choices the Giants made involved trading back into the first round in order to grab a potential franchise quarterback.
While most believed that prospect would be Shedeur Sanders, New York had other preferences.
Instead, they took Ole Miss quarterback Jaxson Dart.
It's a move they may live to regret, according to Bleacher Report's Kristopher Knox.
"Sanders might have been able to unseat Wilson as the starter during training camp. Dart won't, and with a veteran behind center, Daboll and Schoen may need to see early wins to keep their jobs beyond 2025," Knox wrote. "Schematically, Dart is a strong fit for Daboll's offense, and he may be the right quarterback, long term, for the Giants. However, Daboll and Schoen will regret not going with the more pro-ready quarterback if a new front office is building around Dart in 2026."
There's certainly a level of risk that comes with taking Dart over Sanders, but the fact that the latter fell all the way to the fifth round suggests New York may have dodged a bullet.
The questions regarding Dart's profile are legit. He comes from an offense that was built around play action while his ability to go through progressions is extremely limited.
The debate between Dart and Sanders may not have a solidified answer for a while, but all eyes will be on New York given the decision they made.