The Detroit Lions' 2025 NFL draft choices have been met with criticism, notably their first-round selection of Ohio State defensive lineman Tyleik Williams, which puzzled experts due to the team's pressing need for an edge rusher. Despite Williams' impressive collegiate performance, including 136 tackles and 11.5 sacks, analysts like Thor Nystrom were unconvinced of his fit as a first-round pick, especially given the availability of other promising edge rushers. The Lions, having released Za'Darius Smith, were expected to prioritize an edge rusher to complement Aidan Hutchinson but only addressed this need in the sixth round with Boise State's Ahmed Hassanein. This decision has left the Lions ranked near the bottom in draft evaluations. While Williams could eventually prove to be a valuable asset in the middle of the defense, the decision not to focus on edge rushers earlier has raised questions about the team's draft strategy.

The Detroit Lions were criticized for their 2025 NFL draft strategy, particularly for selecting defensive lineman Tyleik Williams in the first round despite a significant need for an edge rusher.

Tyleik Williams, known for his ability as a run defender, had an impressive college career with Ohio State, amassing 136 tackles and 11.5 sacks, but analysts doubted his suitability as a first-round pick due to a perceived lack of pass-rushing capability.

Critics, including Thor Nystrom from FantasyLife, questioned Lions GM Brad Holmes' decision-making, as the team overlooked several quality edge rushers who were still available at the time of their first-round pick.

The Lions' decision to wait until the sixth round to draft edge rusher Ahmed Hassanein from Boise State further fueled criticism, especially after releasing Za'Darius Smith earlier in the offseason.

Other available edge rushers during the draft included Donovan Ezeiruaku, Mike Green, and Nic Sourton, but the Lions opted for Williams, leading to skepticism about their draft approach.

The Lions' draft class was ranked poorly by experts, with some placing them near the bottom of the league, reflecting widespread disapproval of their draft choices.

Despite the backlash, there is potential for Williams to develop into a reliable player in the defensive interior, though the need for edge support remains a contentious issue for the team.

After having a busy start to the offseason, the Detroit Lions entered the 2025 NFL draft and walked out with seven new players to add to their roster for the upcoming season.

Early evaluations of Detroit's 2025 draft class haven't been great, with many experts putting them near the bottom of the league.

On Monday, FantasyLife's Thor Nystrom gave the Lions general manager Brad Holmes' draft an "F," and he was extremely critical of their first-round pick (No. 28 overall), Ohio State defensive lineman Tyleik Williams.

"Holmes' machinations during the draft confused me," Nystrom wrote. "His team, desperate for help on the EDGE, eschewed multiple quality prospects at that position in order to make the most shocking pick of Round 1, DT Tyliek Williams.

Williams is a wide-bodied, quick-footed interior player who is an awesome run defender. I understand the vision. I did not see the pass-rushing profile I need to see for a first-round prospect at that position."

Williams, 22, spent four seasons with the Buckeyes, recording 136 tackles (28 for a loss), 11.5 sacks, 10 passes defensed, one forced fumble and one fumble recovered in 51 career games. He also won a national championship and earned All-Big Ten honors twice and All-American honors once.

Follow The Sporting News on WhatsApp

After Detroit released Za'Darius Smith this offseason, it was clear that they needed to find an edge rusher to play opposite Aidan Hutchinson, but Holmes didn't address the need in free agency or in the draft until the sixth round when they took Boise State's Ahmed Hassanein.

At the time of the Williams pick, Boston College's Donovan Ezeiruaku, Marshall's Mike Green and Texas A&M's Nic Sourton were still on the board.

In fact, the only edge rushers selected before Detroit took Williams were Penn State Abdul Carter (New York Giants), Georgia's Mykel Williams (San Francisco 49ers), Georgia's Jalon Walker (Atlanta Falcons), Texas A&M's Shemar Stewart (Cincinnati Bengals) and Tennessee's James Pearce Jr. (Falcons).

Williams may still end up holding down the middle of the defense and being a solid pick for the Lions, but with how much they needed help on the edge, the selection was a bit surprising.

MORE LIONS NEWS

Detroit Lions get hammered in consensus of experts' 2025 NFL draft grades

Recent Lions draft pick's starting chances take hit after 2025 NFL draft

Za'Darius Smith predicted to ditch Lions reunion for deal with AFC contender

Lions undrafted free agent tracker 2025: Every reported signing for Detroit