B/R's 2026 College Football Winners and Losers from Week 4
Context:
Week 4 delivered chaos and momentum shifts across the college football landscape: Florida surged with a dominant offensive showing, Oklahoma stumbled in a disastrous loss that sparked internal questions, and a dramatic late-score reversal at Michigan underscored the volatility of top programs. Jeremiah Smith continued a record-breaking stretch, elevating Ohio State’s offense and pushing him toward Heisman contention, while Louisville’s crumble at Wake Forest dampened its ACC title hopes. Wisconsin stunned Penn State to spark a hot-seat narrative around Luke Fickell, and Michigan’s fate swung on a last-second Iowa touchdown that mirrored a season’s worth of close finishes. With power conferences tightening up and a fresh slate ahead, the season’s tempo remains unpredictable and status quo-shattering.
Dive Deeper:
Florida overwhelmed Ole Miss 52-28, highlighted by a 498-yard offensive performance and a 5-for-5 second-half TD drive efficiency; Jadan Baugh rushed for 142 yards with three rushing trips to the end zone, while Aaron Philo distributed the ball and minimized turnovers.
Jeremiah Smith posted career highs with 12 receptions, 217 receiving yards, and four touchdowns as Ohio State defeated Illinois 42-19, amplifying his Heisman candidacy while setting a September yardage milestone of 617 yards and seven scores.
Louisville, after a top-25 upset last week, fell 30-27 at home to Wake Forest, with three fourth-quarter drives ending in a turnover on downs, a 42-yard miss, and a 57-yard blocked kick; the loss stung their conference title chances but left the door open for future opportunities.
Texas defender Colin Simmons dominated Tennessee’s line with five sacks in a 20-17 road win, tying a program record for sacks in a single game despite a half-sack negated by a penalty, earning praise from teammate Justin Cryer as arguably the nation’s best defensive talent.
Oklahoma’s issues culminated in a 41-13 defeat at Georgia, including John Mateer’s red-zone fumbles and multiple miscues; the loss raised concerns about offensive consistency, with an upcoming open weekend prompting possible personnel changes.
Michigan watched a dramatic late-zone reversal unfold as Iowa’s Addison Ostrenga and Reece Vander Dee connected on a 29-yard game-winning TD with two seconds left, flipping a close-miss narrative from Week 1’s controversial finish into Week 4's costly loss.
Wisconsin upset 13th-ranked Penn State 24-20 behind a stout second-half defensive effort and a pivotal 72-yard touchdown by tight end Jacob Harris, signaling that Luke Fickell’s rebuilding program may be gaining traction despite ongoing scrutiny.