News Page

Main Content

Three Conservative Catholics on the Conclave and the Future of the Church

The New York Times's profile
The New York Times
Yesterday
Three Conservative Catholics on the Conclave and the Future of the Church

Context:

Conservative Catholics find themselves at odds with the liberalizing tendencies of Pope Francis, leading to a re-evaluation of papal authority within the church. The pontificate of Francis has been marked by controversial decisions, including attempts to restrict the Latin Mass and his handling of sexual abuse cases, which have led to perceptions of chaos and corruption. The conversation among conservative Catholics highlights the generational shifts within the church, as younger priests and Catholics lean more conservatively compared to their predecessors. The upcoming papal conclave presents an opportunity for potential change, with candidates like Cardinal Robert Sarah and Cardinal Pietro Parolin being considered. The broader context of this discussion is the relationship between Catholicism and the secular world, with questions about the future direction of the church in an era defined by digital influences and decentralization from traditional church hierarchy.

Dive Deeper:

  • The discussion reflects on how conservative Catholics feel alienated by Pope Francis' liberalizing approach, which contrasts with the more conservative pontificates of John Paul II and Benedict XVI, leading to a rethinking of papal authority.

  • Pope Francis' tenure has been marked by controversies, including the handling of sexual abuse cases and attempts to suppress the traditional Latin Mass, which have resulted in criticism and perceptions of weakened papal authority.

  • There is a noted generational divide within the church, with younger priests and Catholics tending to be more doctrinally conservative, suggesting that the Francis era might represent a final phase for liberal Catholicism.

  • The upcoming papal conclave is seen as a pivotal moment that could shape the direction of the Catholic Church, with potential candidates like Cardinal Robert Sarah and Cardinal Pietro Parolin being discussed.

  • The conversation highlights the changing relationship between the Catholic Church and the secular world, as terms like 'progress,' 'liberalism,' and 'modern civilization' have shifted in meaning, impacting the church's engagement with contemporary society.

  • The role of the internet and digital platforms in influencing religious thought and engagement is emphasized, suggesting a move towards more decentralized and individualized expressions of faith.

  • The conclave's outcome could significantly impact the church's future, especially in addressing administrative challenges, doctrinal teaching, and the church's public image amidst ongoing scandals and financial issues.

Latest News

Related Stories