Context:

The BBC World Service is hosting a debate to explore whether Donald Trump's presidency is contributing to global safety or instability. With escalating tensions in the Middle East, including recent conflicts between Israel and Iran, the discussion brings together experts such as KT McFarland, Mark Lyall Grant, and Miguel Berger to analyze Trump's diplomatic strategies. Trump has pledged to resolve conflicts in Ukraine and Gaza, advocating for peace talks and urging allies to assume greater security responsibilities. However, his critics argue that his approach is disorganized and has yet to yield successful negotiations or peace deals. The debate aims to assess the impact of Trump's policies on international relations and global security dynamics during his second term in office.

Dive Deeper:

• The debate takes place amidst escalating tensions in the Middle East, highlighted by recent hostilities between Israel and Iran, which have intensified global security concerns.

• Prominent figures such as former US Deputy National Security Adviser KT McFarland and former UK National Security Adviser Mark Lyall Grant participate in the discussion, providing insights into Trump's diplomatic maneuvers.

• Trump has expressed intentions to mediate and resolve ongoing conflicts in regions like Ukraine and Gaza, proposing peace negotiations and urging regional allies to enhance their own security measures.

• Critics of Trump's foreign policy argue that his strategies are inconsistent and lack coherence, leading to skepticism about his ability to achieve diplomatic breakthroughs or lasting peace agreements.

• The debate seeks to evaluate the broader implications of Trump's presidency on international stability, questioning whether his actions have contributed to a safer or more dangerous global environment.