Federal Court Blocks Minnesota's First-In-The-Nation Law Banning Prediction Markets
Context:
A federal judge temporarily blocked Minnesota’s first-in-the-nation law banning prediction markets days before it would take effect, citing likely federal preemption and irreparable harm to operators Kalshi and Polymarket. The ruling highlights a broader struggle over whether states can regulate or ban prediction markets, with the CFTC asserting exclusive federal jurisdiction. The decision delays the law’s impact as lawsuits proceed and the agency moves to define which event contracts to bar. The case illustrates tensions between state gambling controls and federal oversight amid a rapidly expanding prediction-market landscape.
Dive Deeper:
U.S. District Judge Katherine Menendez issued the temporary injunction, finding that Kalshi, Polymarket, and the CFTC were likely to succeed in challenging the Minnesota law and that enforcement would cause irreparable harm to the operators. The law, scheduled to take effect on a Saturday, would have criminalized creating or operating prediction markets or assisting with related activities.
The dispute centers on whether states can regulate these platforms or whether federal law gives the CFTC exclusive authority over event-contract transactions offered by Kalshi and Polymarket.
Minnesota Attorney General Keith Ellison characterized prediction markets as gambling, arguing the state has a right to bar predatory gambling, while acknowledging the legal issues are complex and that he would continue defending the law.
Representatives for Polymarket and Kalshi asserted the decision reinforces that such markets on federally registered exchanges fall under federal jurisdiction, not state rules, signaling a broader legal battleground.
The broader landscape includes multiple lawsuits in which states challenge prediction-market operators as unlicensed gambling operators, alongside federal actions against states over regulation, with the American Gaming Association noting substantial tax-revenue losses tied to these platforms.