News Page

Main Content

Congress Grills College Presidents with an Old Script and New Threats

The New York Times's profile
The New York Times
May 8
Congress Grills College Presidents with an Old Script and New Threats

Context:

During a House committee hearing, college presidents from institutions outside the Ivy League expressed regret for not more aggressively addressing antisemitism on their campuses, amid threats from Republicans to withhold federal funding for non-compliance. The hearing, titled 'Beyond the Ivies,' highlighted that antisemitism is a pervasive issue affecting schools nationwide, not just the Ivy League. University leaders, while showing contrition, faced rigorous questioning, particularly from Republican Elise Stefanik, who demanded clarity on disciplinary actions against students with extreme views. Many universities have since tightened protest-related rules, banned militant groups, and announced initiatives to tackle antisemitism, amid ongoing investigations launched by the Trump administration. Meanwhile, Democrats criticized the hearing as a political play, questioning the administration's commitment to Jewish values while undermining civil rights protections against discrimination.

Dive Deeper:

  • President Wendy Raymond of Haverford College, along with other college leaders, apologized during a House committee hearing for insufficiently addressing antisemitism, stating a commitment to improvement, while facing scrutiny from lawmakers threatening to cut federal funding.

  • The House Committee on Education and the Workforce's hearing, 'Beyond the Ivies,' focused on anti-Semitism issues prevalent in non-Ivy League colleges, highlighting that this is a nationwide problem, with the Trump administration targeting universities in Democrat-leaning states.

  • Congresswoman Elise Stefanik's interrogation of Dr. Raymond centered around a student group's call to dismantle Israel 'by all means necessary,' with Raymond avoiding direct answers regarding disciplinary actions, a tactic previously seen in hearings with Ivy League presidents.

  • In response to increased scrutiny and past protests, many universities have tightened their campus security measures, enacted stricter protest regulations, and taken disciplinary actions against students, leading to a decrease in protest activities.

  • Democratic representative Suzanne Bonamici and ACLU's David Cole criticized the hearing as a political maneuver rather than a genuine effort to combat antisemitism, comparing it to the Communist witch hunts of the 1950s and highlighting cuts to discrimination investigation staff under the Trump administration.

  • The University of Washington faced a federal review of its grants following a protest that led to arrests and campus damage, emphasizing the financial stakes for universities reliant on federal funding, which constitutes a significant portion of their budgets.

  • Universities like Cal Poly have announced plans to combat antisemitism, including creating Jewish studies positions and awareness task forces, while acknowledging the need for better management of campus tensions and protests.

Latest News

Related Stories